Treatment Comparison

Method

Description

Pros

Cons

Fumigation

  • Fumigation is a method of pest control that completely fills an area with gaseous pesticides—or fumigants—to suffocate or poison the pests within.
  • This method also affects the structure itself, affecting pests that inhabit the physical structure, such as bed bugs and drywood termites.
  • 100% effective against all life stages of both bed bugs and drywood termites, including hard to control egg stage
  • Introduced in 1961 by Dow AgroSciences, Vikane fumigant (Sulfuryl Fluoride) has been safely administered hundreds of thousands of times
  • Because it is an inorganic gas, when used in according to label directions, Vikane gas fumigant completely dissipates from a structure following fumigation, leaving no surface residue, odor or film behind.
  • Due to recent improvements in the application of fumigation through containers, trucks and portable fumigation chambers, fumigation is becoming more accessible and affordable, especially in urban areas where bed bugs are quickly becoming the leading pest
  • In cases where structural fumigation can be accomplished, requires no removal of property/items.
  • Clutter is not a concern for fumigation, as the fumigant will penetrate all air spaces, including those within bedding, furniture, electronics and interior/exterior walls
  • Fumigation is not an option for individual units within a multi-unit building (unless surrounding units/bldgs can be evacuated)
  • no residual from fumigation to prevent further re-infestation(s)
  • requires pesticides to prevent future infestations

Chemical

Application of liquid or dust pesticides
  • Residual Effectiveness
  • Several EPA labeled pesticides available for bed bugs
  • May increase bed bug migration
  • Some belongings may have to be discarded
  • Not 100% effective
  • Usually requires several applications to be initially effective

Freezing

Process in which bed bugs are eradicated by rapid freezing
  • Chemical free
  • Kills all bed bug upon direct contact
  • Does not penetrate certain materials
  • No residual effect
  • Clutter may hamper effectiveness
  • Some belongings may have to be discarded

Steam

Direct steam application to bed bug infected area
  • Chemical free
  • Kills all bed bugs upon direct contact
  • Does not penetrate certain materials
  • Moisture left behind may cause damage
  • No residual effect
  • Clutter may hamper effectiveness
  • Not 100% effective

Heat

Use of heating units and fans for circulation to raise and maintain the temperature in an infested area to a lethal degree for several hours
  • Chemical free
  • Kills all bed bug life cycles
  • Penetrates materials
  • Belongings do not have to be discarded
  • While it may be the more expensive option it is the more cost effective
  • 100% effective in eradicating bed bugs in the first treatment 98% of the time
  • Involves detailed pre-treatment space prep by the occupant.
  • Treatment may last several hours
  • Safety Concerns for older buildings
  • Not safe for electronic, antiques or artwork
  • Several reported cases of bed bug heat treatment associated fires

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,115 other followers